Thursday, March 04, 2010

Blogging backlash rebuttal: I don’t hate men. I don’t know what a feminista is. I don’t know from welfare.

I didn't set out this week to write a Black Feminist Manifesto. It wasn't my intention to rally up the Sisterhood with the "I am Woman Hear Me Roar" battle cry. Don't get me wrong, we are awesome though. We totally rock and if we wanted to get matching t-shirts and cabbage patch backwards down Pennsylvania Avenue to "Sisters are doing it for themselves"… well let me know when and I'll order up the frozen margarita machine. I really just wanted to squash the negative rhetoric, get a few things off my chest and share an anecdote or two. And I kinda thought I did that, with far more impact than I expected.

But… wow! Along with the great uplifting and supporting comments came the blowback. Thanks to my readers' passion for the subject, the post calling for a halt on the Black Girl Beatdowns was retweeted and reposted all up and through the internet. Essence.com picked it up, it was "buzzed up" at Yahoo, landed on Digg, Facebook, Twitter, Technorati, Live Journals and places that I didn't even know existed. And I'm thankful, I really am. It's every writer's goal to have their work read. Of course we prefer if it is universally hailed and loved but understand when it is not. And this post most definitely was not. I read some of the comments, some of the tweets and all of the emails sent to me. And though I did not answer a lot of them directly, I thought I'd share a few of my favorites here with my thoughts. Okay, my super snarky thoughts. Ya'll know I try to avoid the super-snark but it's been a long day and I lack my usual diplomacy and tact:

Rebecca on Yahoo! said - Single black women would get more respect if they: 1) didn't have children while single. 2) didn't expect their mothers to raise their children. 3) not be so vocal about their private lives and/or lack thereof. said by a single white woman.

Hey Rebecca, thanks so much for your insightful commentary. Stereotype much? In response I say, I don't have any kids. Therefore my mother isn't raising my kids. And I'm assuming you would like black women to be less vocal about our private lives like… one of those Kardashian girls, Jessica Simpson, Paris Hilton… someone like that? They sure lead by example. Oh and thanks for letting me know you are single and white. I was really interested in that part.

Mr. PantsALot (almost enough said right there) emailed to say: Another mouthy black woman whining. Get a job, lose some weight, eat less chicken and learn to give decent head. Then you'll get a man. You and your blog serve no purpose.

Hi Mister Pants, I'm assuming from your note that if I were a size-four mute making seven figures, snacking on baby greens and swallowing cucumbers whole that we'll be cool and I will then serve a purpose? I'll get to work on that right away because you seem like a catch I'd hate to miss out on. Call me, boo!

On Twitter from a woman who proclaimed herself to be a modern day Incan-Amazon worshipper (I don't know ya'll, I just don't know): You should own your womanist, feminista standards instead of waiting for a man to define you. Men will steal your essence and block your path to the sun whose rays empower and strengthen us. Amazonian woman bask in our self-sufficiency and only ascent to their true queen status when they rid themselves of all men except the ones we birth. You are a sad excuse for encouraging women to depend on a man. Wise up before it's too late to reclaim your soul and body.

Uh Miss Amazon Chick: What? I'm confused and a little scared. There's something both condescending and Oedipal about what you spent fifteen minutes typing to me. I would ask more questions but I find myself terrified of the answers. Since it appears I will miss out on my true queen status, I'll settle for Duchess – wouldn't turn down Countessa status either. Good luck on that sun ray thing though.

On Live Journal Mark shared: So you basically can't get a man so you hate them, why share your pitiful life with the rest of us. Who cares? This is why I date white girls. Yeah I said it and yeah I'm black. What about the fellas, we catch holy hell from the media too, I don't hear your whining about that. Get a life. Peace.

Mark, No one is fooled when you flame throw and then wrap up with "peace". Um, so you have never been on my blog and didn't take the time to look around, huh? You missed my whole I Love Black Men Week? You missed me saying you should get love where you find love, if your love is a white girl – more power to you. Bouge Rule #1 – Bouge is Love… you keep it classy.

For the record, I know black men are catching hell in the media. I see an Ivy League educated Noble Prize Winner in the White House catching hell all day, every day! Let's face it – this is a media-driven society and 24/7/365 news needs to be feed. Nobody escapes the media microscope. Personally, I was a lot happier when I knew a bit less of everybody's business. I just happened to write about single black females… because I am one. We write what we know.

Good readers, do not be dismayed – in one email Tisha from the ATL wiped all the "constructive feedback" from my head. Here's what she wrote.

Dear OneChele,

My husband passed away in Iraq over two years ago. Since then I have really struggled raising our seven-year old daughter. Not financially but keeping her grounded and positive without a strong male figure. She worries about me, I worry about her. I come home from work, get food on the table, get her settled and then finally pop open my laptop with a big glass of wine. The blogosphere is where I go to unwind. I'll come back to that in a second. My daughter and I watch the morning news shows together. One day last week when I ran upstairs, she caught wind of the story about single black females dying alone. On the way to school she told me she never wanted to get married and leave me. I asked her why and she said she didn't want me to end up alone eaten by cats. You know that was a bolt to my heart to hear those words coming out of her young mouth. I told her not to worry about it, it wasn't going to happen. That afternoon she came out of the school dragging some grown man with her. My child had walked up to one the teachers, grilled him and asked him if he wanted to date her mother. You know I wanted to die when she pulled that man up to the car. Man had the nerve to be cute too. Everyday since she asked me what I'm going to do so I don't get eaten by cats. Last night I read your blog. I printed it out and read it to her this morning. She smiled and said Oh Mama you can take your time finding a new man or you can be okay alone. I said yes I could. She was happy. Unfortunately she strutted up to cute teacher and told him My mama doesn't need you anymore, she's gonna be okay. So I thank you Ms. OneChele, your blog post gave me and my daughter what we needed to make it through another day. Thanks , Tisha in Atlanta

As I dab my eyes with the Kleenex let me say – Tisha, you're welcome… and you may want to holla at cute teacher… just sayin' your daughter may have picked a winner.

Okay BougieLand, thoughts or comments? Anyone have a CLUE what an Incan-Amazonian Sun Worshipper is? Don't you just love when a post all about keeping it peaceful causes folks to go completely left and back again? Fellas, get your boys Pants and Mark… please.

42 comments:

sunt97 said...

I always crack up listening to hater mail. Black men and white people have this crazy misconception that black women are all overweight, whining because they want a "good" man and that they have a bunch of kids. It's so pathetic that these folks won't look in the mirror and see what they are looking at. Really only black women talk about waiting to find love? Seriously, um, what about that hit show "Sex inthe City", four white women desperately looking for love, having a child and not being married and I believe they even talked about abortions, but white women thought that show was the best thing since sliced bread. And oh, the poor black man, yes we are behind you and push you to be the best, but really you think we hate on men. No, we push you to be the best you can be and overcome what the media says about you but men just aren't feeling that. Love your blog and it has sooooooooo much purpose.

Tiffany
http://liferequiresmorechocolate.blogspot.com

Sarah said...

This morning when I got up, I looked out the window at the piles of snow, the misty fog in the distance, the frost on the cars, and the bright blue sky. It is another day to try to do my best and not succumb to the negativity that is generated by the little stress pressure cooker of life. I'm sorry those dweebs felt like they had to dump all their negativity on you. You had a point. You made it. Actually, I think it speaks to all women. When negativity comes my way I picture in my mind a rock in a stream of water. Let it pass over you and continue on its way 'cause it doesn't belong to you. Anyway, I have to get on with the business of the day, but I wanted to wish you a happy day first. Best of wishes.

rozb said...

I just discovered your blog through your article on Essence.com and I love it! Now if we can only get Essence and others to stop doing the same thing they say MSM is doing to us. I swear - Essence is so schizophrenic because in one breath lack women are fabulous and doing it well, and in the next they are trying to tell us how to snag, keep, and marry a man. Between that and their whole "Will You Marry Me?" craptastic contest, Essence is basically talking out of both sides of their neck.

Keep doing this blog, young lady - it is wonderful!

ithopiamckinney said...

Let me tell you OneChele you are not making a point if you don't have haters, that's just the way the world spins on its axis. Like Vivika says, "I put in where? Back there!" (with the hand motion showing back there). Your blog is the shizniz! Loving it in the Bahamas and you like have to come on my show like seriously!

Winter137 said...

Essence always contradict themselves e.g. Don't over spend and read our 4 month article on how to budget on page 10 ......p. 1-30 ( $500 purses, $300 shoes, etc)

Winter137 said...

Onechele you're responses are hilarious -

Hey Rebecca, thanks so much for your insightful commentary. Stereotype much? In response I say, I don't have any kids. Therefore my mother isn't raising my kids. And I'm assuming you would like black women to be less vocal about our private lives like… one of those Kardashian girls, Jessica Simpson, Paris Hilton… someone like that? They sure lead by example. Oh and thanks for letting me know you are single and white. I was really interested in that part

Hi Mister Pants, I'm assuming from your note that if I were a size-four mute making seven figures, snacking on baby greens and swallowing cucumbers whole that we'll be cool and I will then serve a purpose? I'll get to work on that right away because you seem like a catch I'd hate to miss out on. Call me, boo!

Ignore the haters

RavensLady said...

I really want to ask these people exactly how many black women do you know? I am always confused (sarcasm, lol) by folk who have met (not know) 1 1/2 black women and feel like they know ALL of us...da hell?!

Yumyo said...

Good morning Bougie. I tripped over your blog about 15 minutes ago. It was almost like a 'six degrees of..' episode. I was on necolebitchie.com. I clicked on one of her favorite blog sites abelleinbrooklyn.com. Read the first post, clicked on a link and the rest is history. I just wanted to say I'm diggin your blog. I'm going to practically bookmark it and check it out every now and then. I added you on Facebook and Twitter.

melhopkins2012 said...

Awww...babygirl is to precious! Those other folks - well we haven't started the "war against stupidity" yet - so they are safe. Wait you can direct them to literacy.gov .

midwestdominicana said...

Just a little glass of haterade to cap off your evening. Wow. Is this not the essence of leaping before looking? It sounds like every one of those negative nellies had a bigoted chip on their shoulders. It's a shame that they want to take whatever BET, MTV, Essence and the local urban radio stations give them as truth without so much as getting to know more than 1 1/2 brown person. As the world continues to turn. What do Jill Scott and Jay-Z say? Hate on me and thank you.

Brown Babe said...

*scratching my head* did these folks not read the article before they posted their comments...I had to go back and read through it again to make sure we were talking about the same post.

This was not about man hating, whining, complaining, stereotypical black girl neck rolling or anti-feminist man chasing...just enough already STOP with the doomed black woman madness.

Did I miss something? *Confuzzled*

On another note, I'm about to print this out and circulate amongst my teen sister & cousins who worry incessantly about the ticking of my biological clock!

brendakay50 said...

"Tisha in Atlanta" had me crying and laughing. GOD bless her and her lovely {and wise beyond her years} daughter.

Inca-Amazon woman needs to get off of Twitter, walk outside for a few hours - the fresh air will work wonders for the brain cells.

Rebecca can kiss our collective bougie, beautiful and successful behinds. I am being too snarly to wonder if Rebecca has a best selling novel in stores and available through online retailers?

Pantsalot and Mark sound like they are related to Like Riley...

ASmith said...

Um... Tisha's daughter is too cute for my life. I love her go get 'em attitude. I spent all my time as a lil kid side-eying dudes who tried to holla at my mother (I still side-eye them, but secretly, because that's not my business... well, I mean it is, but ya'll know what I mean)

As for the naysayers. I can't stand no-reading-behind folks. If you don't like it, I dig it, but can you read it first? ::woosah:: I'm also not convinced they don't do it just so they can get their 15 mins of shine. UH-HUH.

Speaking of which, Chele, you ever get responses when you post the highlights of the crazy e-mails you get?

Not touching the Incan-whatsababble with a 10 foot pole. Thanks.

Apple turned Peach said...

I found your blog as a result of a link from the blog www.abelleinbrooklyn.com. I love your blog!
Let the haters hate and continue doing and being you!

Hidi said...

I apologize, Onechele, but I have to laugh at all this nonsense. ROTFL

People are soooo crazy: Incan-Amazonian Sun Worshipper (needs to find God), Rebecca (needs to return to her trailer park), Mr. PantsAlot (needs to head to a clinic; might have a STD) and Mark ( self help books; I think you are VERY insecure and it's showing BIG TIME).

As for Tisha and her daughter, awwww that was a beautiful story. {wiping eyes}. I am happy she printed out Onechele's post, so her daughter can understand that people in the media are a@%holes. {wink}

Alisha said...

Love your response to Mark. "Keep it classy." I like that.

Just me! said...

Okay where to begin: not touching the sun worshipper thing ??...

black men who feel the need to respond with more broad stroke attacks and add they don't date us have missed the ENTIRE point, which is: Enough already! if that is what you feel you need to do to be you, then GO! WE ARE NOT LOOKING FOR YOU AND ARE NOT PRESSED...just stop with the BW bashing. dude, it's not a good look, lol, and it's beyond tired

finally: yes media is still racially biased. BUT the huge difference is that women are still primarily evaluated on beauty, how she measures up to a widespread and dominant concept of beauty while MEN ARE NOT. Even when men are rated in appeal and masculinity, the black man isn't deemed at the bottom of the ladder for his natural African features the way black women are. (They are moreso judged on power/money and can basically come in any outer package.) To ignore that pervasive and obvious fact is dishonest. All of us in this society are brainwashed by these images, and men, being more visual-based in attraction, usually have to be more conscious, self-evolved (especially spiritually), well-traveled, open-minded, self-loving to even recognize the racially and socially toxic campaign, let alone learn to think outside of the box.
Just my observations. Oh! and for the most part, black men who love themselves and have had positive examples of male/female black love, and have their own personal power don't feel the need to engage in black woman bashing--regardless of who they are involved with.

OneChele said...

I should do a comparative analysis of the women of SATC vs. Waiting to Exhale. Oooo - imagine the feedback then ;-)

OneChele said...

Thank you and welcome!

Sasha Stiletto said...

Amazon what?! God Bless Mark - so it's all about a head game and a 20 inch waist, huh? Ugh.
Please tell Tisha to write back in and tell us what happens with Cute Teacher!

OneChele said...

Please let me know when someone invents the antidote for ignorance. I will pay to have it misted from the sky.

JaymeC said...

Okay I know what a feminist is and I know what a fashionista is so is a "feminista" a blend of the two? And what does that have to do with Incan Sun Worship. Lord help us.
The thing is, even though people threw shade, they read some of it. Maybe a kernel of truth will stick. That's the thing about great writing, some of it stays with you even if you agree with the content.

And I see your snark is still on point! You know you slayed with the 7-figure size 6 cucumber reference!

When is the DC Cabbage Patch for the Sisterhood meet up? I'll bring the chips and salsa - LOL. (And you know if we ever really had one the fellas would be lined up watching... yeah they would)

OneChele said...

Sometimes I hear Jill Scott singing in my head. If I ever have a bio-pic of my life (no thank you), she would be the soundtrack.

Rob said...

Well I'll speak up for the fellas - Mark is an idiot. Mr. Pants is an idiot. Not that ever have complaints with a woman's um- dedication to the craft of love (whew) but if those are his top 4 criteria for a mate - I wish him luck with that.

OneChele said...

Truer words never spoken. Most people who feel good and secure about themselves don't have time to tear down other people. They are about business.

LeonX said...

Exactly. It's one thing to to disagree and be constructive about it. It's another thing to pull out the cannons of vitriol.

Andrea M said...

Chele - you do you, girl. We got you.

Cassie said...

You know we're giving you "Good Man" Points for "cannons of vitriol", right?! Score.

OneChele said...

Yes, I do get responses back from the crazies I call out. Crazy stays crazy girl.

Mocha Dude Speaks said...

I'm so confused. If they disliked the the article so much - why take the time to write about it... Me thinks they doth hate too much...

OneChele said...

LMAO - I hope they read your sage advice and follow it.

OneChele said...

Thank you and welcome!

Vonmiwi said...

This is too cute and I'm still laughing at the comments as I attempt to type this statement! I would think an Incan-Amazonian Sun Worshipper is an indigenous woman from South or Central America who still lives in La jungla .

sunt97 said...

They'd hate that blog too and probably say there are no similarities.

Tiffany
http://liferequiresmorechocolate.blogspot.com

keishabrown said...

i've been worshipping shoes.. and all this time i was supposed to be worshipping the sun?? ooooooh!! glad that's been cleared up now!
i too would like to attend this parade...i'll plan the after party. LOL.
and i'd like to say for the record - since men seem to be reading your articles, my head game is perfectly fine thank you. perhaps i'm single because i chose to get rid of THEM since their games WERENT. chew on THAT!!
in response to another blog post on being black and single, i wrote this: http://www.chroniclesofasocialesquire.com/blog/2010/3/2/dating-diaries-a-readers-reflections-on-love-and-life.html

OneChele said...

See now, a Shoe Worshipping tribe I could co-sign on ;-)

OneChele said...

Kudos for trying to define the Incan-Amazonian thing - excellent attempt at making the insane sane - LOL!

TNatrice said...

I am confused as to how they got that you hate men and you were waiting on a man to define you while celebrating your aunt who was AWESOME! At first I was furious and came over here to give some sharp tongued support for you and the rest of the readers but something strange happened (in a good way). The most recent comments of folks laughing at the sun worshipper and the black man setting those other two fools straight in a lighthearded manner instantly changed my attitude and made me smile. I'm happy they answered the way that they did because it actually calmed me down and helped me to realize that people are ignorant and me being snarky won't really help-unless I get to see them in person and then, baby, its on! LoL

At any rate, we support you, we're reading and we will definitely let the words fly when people take your post and twist the words to say something totally different. Just keep writing and being honest, we will keep reading!

onesoutherndiva said...

Incan-Amazonian Sun Worshipper = someone who really needs Jesus. Let us pray...

OneChele said...

*bows head* Amen.

Kandia said...

Loved your response to Rebecca...."like one of those Kardashian girls"....LOL!!! Yeah you can't get any more "private" than that. **rolling eyes**

Anonymous said...

hi!This was a really brilliant topic!
I come from itlay, I was fortunate to discover your theme in baidu
Also I get much in your topic really thank your very much i will come again

LinkWithin

Related Posts with Thumbnails