Thursday, February 04, 2010

Just in time for Black History Month, I'm forced to wonder: How black is "black enough"?

Allow me to share a BougieTale from Wednesday afternoon:

Michele Grant sits on a conference call with her agent (a self-described Jewish New Yorker) and two representatives from a west coast film production company. They are interested in optioning my book for a film. The problem is we want to keep the integrity of the story; otherwise we could just sell the option, take the money and run. But very rarely are first-time unknown authors giving the opportunity to stay involved. Now I still may take the money and sprint but first we thought we'd try to see if we could keep a little artistic control. We have met with two other companies. This is our third of five meetings and we are hearing the exact same thing. So much so that my agent and I are on Yahoo Messenger keeping each other sane. Here is the latest:

Them: "Your storyline is compelling but your heroine is ethnically ambiguous."

My Agent: "I beg your pardon?"

Them: "We mean… we know she's black… African-American… but she doesn't really act like it."

Me (thinking Oh Really Now?): "I see."

Them: "And your hero, can he be a little more blue collar?"

Me (thinking for the last time – He's an ARCHITECT): "umm, er-"

Them: "And then we'd like you add in some scenes that are more colorful."

Me: "Colorful?"

Them: "Less mainstream. Something more suit to a wider Black audience."

Me: "I'm sure I don't know what you mean." [I knew exactly what they meant but I just wanted them to say it.]

Them: "Well you have a barbecue scene and a night club scene and a church scene – those are great but maybe you could expand those and have more quintessential ethnic moments?"

My agent (affronted): "Quintessential ethnic moments?"

Them: "We're just going to speak plainly and we don't want you to take offense. Okay?"

Me (already offended but resigned): "Sure, go ahead."

Them: "It's almost mainstream enough to crossover but your best idea is to appeal to a black base. And right now, it's just not black enough."

Me (slowly through gritted teeth): "Not. Black. Enough. I see."

Agent: "Thank you guys, I don't think it's a fit."

Them: "Well but-"

CLICK.

My agent started apologizing to me, I cut her off. I told her it was the story of my life. Just black enough to be considered black, but quite black enough… whatever the hell that means.

Later, as I recounted the story to a friend of mine, she got angry. She told a story about going out on a sales call with her manager. She was flattered and surprised to be asked since she was the junior sales executive and new to the company. As they drove towards the sales visit, she realized that they were heading to a black part of town. She began to wonder if this was why she was chosen to attend. Her suspicions were affirmed when he turned to her as they pulled up and said, "Hey, I'm going to let you take the lead on this one. But do you think you could "black it up" a little in there? You come across kinda white bread sometimes. You know, drop your g's some, get loose." [say it with me now... LASER-BEAM SIDE-EYE]

She said two things stopped her from going off – she was in the middle of a neighborhood she knew nothing about and she needed the job. But after winning the account, she waited a few days and then sent an email detailing the incident word for word and cc'd his supervisors and Human Resources. She dropped in words like "tokenism" and "emotional distress." Shortly thereafter her supervisor was transferred but she got the stigma of being "a troublemaker" (read Uppity Negro) and it stayed with her until she left the company three months later.

Le Sigh people. It's 2010. Do we really need to tell people that euphemisms like "colorful" and "ethnic" are not a very well-disguised? Do we really still need to give someone the side-eye for using a term like "black it up"? Diggity-damn, do I really need to prove my "blackness" to sell a script? Just what the feazy is "quintessential ethnicity" anyway? Let me dig around in the stereotype files.

Ah here we go: Should my characters enter each scene carrying some form of cooked chicken parts? Should they discuss weaves vs. natural hair at the drop of a hat? Should I go into more details about rims and chains? Should I have one character who adds, "Know what I'm sayin'?" to the end of every sentence? Should I place a scene in a check-cashing store, barbershop, or nail salon? Should someone be an aspiring rapper/professional athlete at the age of 35? Should I make sure someone has a black velvet picture of Malcolm X, MLK, Biggie and Tupac with angels' wings hanging up in the living room? Should a fight break out over blue Koolaid? Is that blackity-black enough?

Okay, I've vented. Moving on. But I'll say this one thing: Obama is in the White House but we are still generations away from true post-racism.

Hmm, that was a kind of white bread closing to this post, let me "black it up" a little: We still 50-cent short of a dolla dolla bill, ya'll. Ain't that right, BougieLand? Ya'll keep it real and greasy fo' sheezy, ya dig! Holla at cha girl! I'm out. Deuces, truces and nan-mo excuses! Peace! [drops mic and exits, stage left]

But that did get me to thinking - just how black am I? I came up with a completely offensive quiz full of our worst stereotypes. Please take it in the super-snarky spirit in which I created it:

Thoughts? Comments? Similar experiences?

33 comments:

J B said...

Clearly this agent grew up on bootleg Amos and Andy videotapes. I've read two of the three scenes in question...HIlarious and PERFECT given the personalities of the characters involved. Who are Black. Duh.

I weep for people, sometimes..

AppleBerryMIA said...

Hot mess. I was complaining to a co-worker the other day that we're either Li'l Wayne or Barack Obama - they can't process the in-betweens.

RavensLady said...

dang! -20 *packing up my bag*

I just got revoked out of Blackland...*cries and runs away*

OneChele said...

LOL! Come on back... these just jokes!

derek love said...

You went IN! Deuces, truces and nan-mo excuses! BWAHAHA!
This quiz is the funniest thing I've seen a while.
BTW, I read the book - good job. WTH does "ethnically ambiguous" mean? Your heroine was exactly as she should be.
Stick to your guns.

Grace said...

My favorite (NOT) recollection from my first job is sitting in a meeting when they began to discuss target demographics. One person turns to me and said, "Well what do black people want to see Grace?" The Hell? I gotta speak for the whole race now? According to your quiz, I'm not black enough anyway - HA!

diamond life said...

*snickering* Yes Chele, have your characters cabbage patch into the room carrying buckets of KFC.

Kiki said...

I scored a -10. Was it the salmon that did me in?
All jokes aside, these stories are sobering indeed. Just when I think we've taken three steps forwward, I realize there are still some people lagging WAY far behind.

OneChele said...

That token thing is a subject for an entire week of posts for sure. Having grown up almost always being the only black in the room, class, meeting, restaurant. Sometimes you just have to grit your teeth. There is no way someone who hasn't been put in the situation regularly for years could understand or relate.

Steve said...

My first job as a trainer at a large "chain" gym, we were setting up for the day. All of a sudden the manager says, "Steve, you wanna pick the music? Maybe spice it up with some rap or something?" I probably listened to less rap than half the white guys in there yet he singled me out in front of everybody. I just clenched my jaw and said - Naw man, whatever you have is fine. Of course everyone was like - oh he didn't mean anything by it. And that's the problem.

mocha dude speaks said...

In the words of Marvin Gaye - makes me wanna holla, throw up both my hands...

OneChele said...

Ugh. That falls under things never to ask black people.

beautifulcurare said...

Heeeeeey now! I'm "black enough"!!! *doing the Roger Rabbit*

LOL..but seriously, that is a daggone shame! "Quintessential ethnic moments"...WTH? People act as if they don't know that they're being offensive, but you can't fool me....I give the *side eye* often...

Pure Choco said...

I answered with what I thought were the most outlandish answers and got "truly black" - OneChele that is hilarious! We have to have sense of humor about it because otherwise we wold be crying and fighting all the time!

SBChitownChick said...

FTW for the Black Sheep video in the beginning of the quiz! My black card was revoked... I'm okay with this. LOL!

Rob said...

The BougieTale is sad but expected. The quiz is hilarious. I needed a laugh today.

true2me said...

I blame the ignorance of the Black culture for this "Black enough" shyt.

I HATE IT.

Let's just try and keep calm and remind them that they are being completely idiotic and ignorant and its wrong to assume you know how anyone's lifestyle should be or not.

Chele, keep writing the way YOU WANT. I love the way you represent .....

She's Savvy said...

Great Post! I chuckled at some of the comments, because it's amazing to me the things people say and think it's acceptable. I remember when I was in a training program with AT&T and was asked to attend a dinner for some students (from HBCUs) who were in town for a competition. The guy in HR who invited me said I was chosen because "we want to have more people like you in the program." Clearly, I could read between the lines and knew what he meant. In my reviews, it was always "she's so articulate and polished." While, my non-Black counterparts were getting more substantive comments.

In Corporate America it's like they want you to be extra-Black or they think you're trying to assimilate. I'm glad you stood up for yourself and didn't change your writing to be another stereotypical Black author. Lord knows we have enough of them already.

Man's World said...

Whew - I'm "black enough" - it was close though. PS. don't be hating on a rib sammich ;-)

OneChele said...

Congrats on your black status ;-)

Hidi said...

I just took the quiz..guess what? I am really black. Yeah for me. I have been confuse all my life. (pure sarcasm)

Seriously, the reps from the movie production company are stupid. I laugh at the "quintessential ethnic moments".

SMDH :(

ASmith said...

I don't even know if I could adequately express the MANY side-eyes and blank stares I gave the stories in this post.

"black it up?" OHMIGOD I would've spit fire... and I would've "blacked it up" sho' nuff... but right inside that car and ::whew:: Ok. Lemme calm down. ::breathe::

Last year, a well-known historically black sorority requested a meeting with the office I work in. The topics they wanted to discuss spanned across a few lines and only intersected one or two of the 5 or 6 issues I work on. However, my boss's boss asked me to sit in on the meeting with him.

I knew IMMEDIATELY what it was about. There was really nothing I could bring to the meeting (aside from my obvious charm and quick wit) that my boss's boss didn't already know/would be able to relay. I toiled over what to do for weeks and I had all kinds of advice, ranging from "give him a piece of your mind" to "this could be an opportunity for you to shine, so shut up." One person gave me pretty sage advice for my situation: this could open the door for more opportunities to take meetings with him. Wait and see how it pans out.

Ultimately, I decided to wait to see how the meeting transpired before I determined, what, if anything to say to him. The meeting went well, I was able to shine and there were no requests for me to act a certain way. 2 months later, he asked me to join a meeting with him on some major issues, and I was the only black face in the room.

Having said all that, and even given the way it all worked out for me, I still question the way I handled it. No one wants to be the token black kid. It sucks and lawd Jeebus white people be trippin' with that.

What's more, since when did white people know what black is? THAT's the part that burns me up. How can you tell me about something you haven't lived not nary no day in all your privileged life.

smartgirl said...

I can't totally understand! I interviewed for a faculty position at an Ivy League institution. They didn't hire me and the only reason I heard was because I "wasn't black enough" with my light-skinned, proper English and advanced degrees! Plus, I didn't convince them that I embraced the "hip hop culture", WTH??? Keep it moving, someone will like the book the way it is!

1xellus1 said...

It can be so frustrating to have to represent the entire Black community just because you are the only Black person on the job. People are disarmed by your approachableness & inevitably they ask you all the questions they wanted but were afraid to ask.
When I was 19 I was theee only Black person working @ the GAP (district hq) & they asked me..."Do you guys tan?". UGH! Or how about when the closet bigotted suprvr on my husband's job gave him the old "you are so articulate & a CREDIT TO YOUR RACE" back handed compliment. Another experience he had @ work a coworker told him & his darker Dominican coworker that if they visited his home, he'd have to put the dog up because he "doesn't like Black people." RIDICULOUS. Or how about when a close friend of mine asked me about celebrity crushes & asked me who I thought was attractive. Immediately, she jumped in with guesses, "Denzel Washington? Will Smith". I cut her one of my sideline looks & said, "Brad Pitt" just to knock her off of her rocker. Like it wasn't "OK for me to think a person of a different ethnicity was attractive. I was mortified. She was what I thought to be one of the most liberal, open, generous, sincere persons I'd ever met period. It proved that no matter how progressive we may think we are, people are shackled (for lack of a better adjective) by preconceived ideas & judgements. They are no doubt effected by the media & personal experiences. I'll save the best for last. My boss one day told me that I didn't look all Black. I just laughed & asked him what he was talking about? He talked about my complexion & my features. Granted in this melting pot none of us can claim to be 100% PURE from the Motherland. It was a completely inappropriate comment. Wooo Saaa, Woo Saaaa.

OneChele said...

All I can say to that those stories is "Wow" - {{}} <-- virtual hug.

Athena.Long said...

I'm thinking about writing my dissertation about this very subject (after I find a program that I fit into)...

Support your fellow Bourgeois!

(and I just realized how apropos my avatar was for this very post.... that was a great moment in political history)

OneChele said...

Love the avatar! I'm waiting for "Still That One" '12 ;-)

Jara said...

I wish we were post-other races defining blackness for us. Hell, I wish we were post-blacks defining blackness for us.

Chin up, Chele. In 2003, Tyler Perry was in the same situation you're in: "Ya'll should HEAR the ideas that Fox has for Madea. They don't want any mention of Christianity, which just isn't gonna happen. And that's the least crazy of their ideas. I will keep turning these people down until I can do Madea my way."

That was back when Tyler sold his videos for $40+ (with S&H).

Enter LionsGate, BlockBuster, Target, cha-ching! and haters extraordinaire.

Btw, according to your quiz, I'm 0% black. "Black Pass Revoked!"

At least I can be pres-o-dent!

*shrug*

Jara said...

Sounds like the script for a typical "urban" KFC or Mickey D's commercial.

Jara said...

This also goes for those militant blacks who are always swearing what they'd do in front of The Man but have never had to actually mix it up with said Man (at work, school, dorm, nothing). Being multi-culti is a unique dance that challenges even the most rhythmic of us.

I contend that living while black AMONGST whites is just as hardcore (and as much of an authentic black experience) as these manufactured ghetto tales I hear on the radio.

Mr. Analytical said...

Sad but true. I'm rushing to get my black ass ready for work, I wanted to chime in real quick. I haven't read all the comments so forgive me if I copy someone else's sentiments. You know us Black folk are good for stealing.

Anyway, the funny thing about all of this is...when people request you to "act more black" which is the equivalent of saying you "aren't black enough." At the same time if you did act "black enough" they would scowl and be too good (or intimidated) to deal with you in all your "blackness" to begin with.

lose/lose situation.

pluky said...

Your experience with the Hollywooders makes me wonder how "Eve's Bayou" ever got made. One of the things I found most fascinating about the film was its nonchalant depiction of upper middle black life before the civil rights era.

As to my own "amusing" work story. Asked if I was interested in the office basketball team. Politely declined. "Why?", I was asked, jokingly. "Did I think I was too good?" Blank stare at the response that I never learned to play, but if they ever started a competive volleyball team, let me know.

Athena.Long said...

I made this for a bunch of my friends to wear on t-shirts immediately after McCain made that statement...

If you want me to fashion one to reflect your sentiment, let me know and I will see what I can do =]

LinkWithin

Related Posts with Thumbnails